MUD SLINGING AND A REALITY CHECK!!!!!
The House members voted on the Omnibus Health and Human Services Finance bill. This legislation covers healthcare policy and finance.
THE "NO-SPIN" RESULTS:
THE VOTES ARE RIGHT DOWN PARTY LINES-so much for getting along!
What does the Bill do?
FUNDING
1. Makes a $8.18 billion investment in healthcare to make it more affordable for all. This is an INCREASE in funding from the present budget.
2. Provides a 2.26 percent Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for long-term care providers (nursing home workers, etc?)
3. Provides 5 percent rate increase for home health care services
4. Reduces fees for parents of children with disabilities who receive assistance
5. Removes retroactive life estate liens.
In 2003, you couldn't hide your assets in a life estate to get out of paying for your long-term care and forcing the cost on other taxpayers. The Dems made this a winning issue in the 2004 campaign. The language in the bill fixes the problem by removing the retroactivity of the provision but saying if you created a life estate after Aug. 1, 2003, you must use the life estate to pay for long-term care rather than forcing ot her taxpayers to pay for you.
The DFL voted against reforms:
REFORM
1. Closes loophole that permitted state-funded sex change operations
2. Removes adults without children from eligibility for the state-funded insurance MinnesotaCare. This brings the program back to its original mission focusing on the the kids.
3. College students with access to private insurance through parents or their college can no longer receive the state-funded insurance MinnesotaCare
4. Slows down the growth of healthcare costs from 19 percent to 14.5 percent
----------------------------
Following in lock-step the DFL failed again at fiscal policy and played the special interests card again....
Democrats voted against a 15 percent increase in health care spending that will make health care more affordable for all Minnesotans.
Democrats voted against a long overdue COLA increase for our health care workers.
Democrats voted against fixing life estate liens.
Democrats voted against abuse of publicly funded welfare health care.
Democrats voted against restricting taxpayer funded abortions.
Democrats voted for taxpayer funded sex change operations.
The list of Democrats who voted against the bill includes: Lillie 55A, Slawik 55B, Greiling and Scalze....
Anderson, I., Atkins, Bernardy, Carlson, Clark, Davnie, Dill, Dittrich, Dorn, Eken, Ellison, Entenza, Goodwin, Greiling, Hansen, Hausman, Hilstrom, Hilty, Hornstein, Hortman, Jaros, Johnson, R., Johnson, S., Juhnke, Kahn, Kelliher, Larson, Latz, Lesch, Liebling, Lieder, LEON LILLIE 55A, Loeffler, Mahoney, Mariani, Moe, Mullery, Nelson, M. Opatz, Paymar, Peterson, A., Peterson, S. Poppe, Rukavina, Ruud, Sailer, Scalze, Sertich, Sieben, Simon, NORA SLAWIK 55B, Solberg, Thao, Thissen, Wagenius, Walker, Welti
AMENDMENTS
Fritz A50
Fritz offered amendment prohibiting nursing homes from using the 2.26 percent COLA increase for anything but nursing staff salaries. The COLA increase could not be used for the clerical staff or janitors who help keep the place running. This amendment was opposed by the nursing home groups made up of nursing staff and administrators.
Democrats who voted for this amendment include: Lillie 55A, Slawik 55B, Greiling and Scalze....
Anderson, I., Atkins, Bernardy, Carlson, Clark, Davnie, Dill, Dittrich, Dorn, Eken, Ellison, Entenza, Fritz, Goodwin, Greiling, Hansen, Hausman, Hilstrom, Hilty, Hornstein, Hortman, Hosch, Huntley, Jaros, Johnson, R., Johnson, S., Juhnke, Kahn, Kelliher, Koenen, Larson, Latz, Lenczewski, Lesch, Liebling, Lieder, Lillie, Loeffler, Mahoney, Mariani, Marquart, Moe, Mullery, Murphy, Nelson, M. Opatz, Otremba, Paymar, Pelowski, Peterson, A., Peterson, S. Poppe, Rukavina, Ruud, Sailer, Scalze, Sertich, Sieben, Simon, Slawik, Solberg, Thao, Thissen, Wagenius, Walker, Welti
Kelliher A41
Kelliher offered an amendment requiring medical facilities to provide information on the morning after abortion pill to sexual assault victims.
Here are the Democrats who supported the promotion of abortion: Lillie 55A, Slawik 55B, Greiling and Scalze....
Anderson, I., Atkins, Bernardy, Carlson, Clark, Davnie, Dill, Dittrich, Dorn, Ellison, Entenza, Goodwin, Greiling, Hansen, Hausman, Hilstrom, Hilty, Hornstein, Hortman, Huntley, Jaros, Johnson, R., Johnson, S., Kahn, Kelliher, Larson, Latz, Lesch, Liebling, Lieder, Lillie, Loeffler, Mahoney, Mariani, Moe, Mullery, Nelson, M. Paymar, S.Peterson, Poppe, Rukavina, Ruud, Sailer, Scalze, Sertich, Sieben, Simon, Slawik, Solberg, Thao, Thissen, Wagenius, Walker, Welti Abesent: Murphy
Wagenius A53
Wagenius offered an amendment that would have put in statute language claiming farmers cause spontaneous abortions with the pesticides and nitrates (atrazine) they use.
The Democrats who believe farmers cause abortions include:
Atkins, Bernardy, Carlson, Clark, Davnie, Dittrich, Dorn, Ellison, Entenza, Goodwin, Greiling, Hausman, Hilstrom, Hilty, Hornstein, Hortman, Huntley, Jaros, Johnson, R., Johnson, S., Kahn, Kelliher, Larson, Latz, Lesch, Liebling, Lieder, Loeffler, Mahoney, Mariani, Mullery, Murphy, Nelson, M., Paymar, Peterson, A., Peterson, S., Poppe, Ruud, Scalze, Sieben, Simon, Slawik, Solberg, Thao, Thissen, Wagenius, Walker
THIS IS REALLY AN OUTRAGEOUS AMENDMENT: Otremba A71
Otremba offered an amendment forcing the average taxpayer to pay for the long-term care of the rich. Her amendment said if you put your money in an irrevocable trust for your children, the state can't use the money to pay for your long-term care. As a result, YOU get stuck with the bill.
Democrats who voted for this amendment include: Lillie 55A, Slawik 55B, Greiling and Scalze....
Anderson, I., Atkins, Bernardy, Carlson, Clark, Davnie, Dill, Dittrich, Dorn, Eken, Ellison, Entenza, Fritz, Goodwin, Greiling, Hansen, Hausman, Hilstrom, Hilty, Hornstein, Hortman, Hosch, Huntley, Jaros, Johnson, R., Johnson, S., Juhnke, Kahn, Kelliher, Koenen, Larson, Latz, Lenczewski, Lesch, Liebling, Lieder, LEON LILLIE 55A, Loeffler, Mariani, Marquart, Moe, Mullery, Murphy, Nelson, M. Opatz, Otremba, Paymar, Pelowski, Peterson, A., Peterson, S. Poppe, Rukavina, Ruud, Sailer, Scalze, Sertich, Sieben, Simon, Slawik, Solberg, Thao, Thissen, Wagenius, Walker, Welti Absent: Mahoney
To view the bill, go to?
http://www.revisor.leg.state.mn.us/revisor/pages/search_status/status_detail.php?b=House&f=HF1422&ssn=0&y=2005
AND NOW THE "SPIN"....WHAT THE DEMS WILL SAY
Those nasty republicans are cutting too much.
WHAT is the reality and what really is the GOP doing?
This bill still signifies a 15 percent increase in the Health and Human Services budget. The fiscal responsible republicans are merely slowing the growth in spending in this area. If we continued to allow this part of the budget to grow out of control, we would need to double income taxes every eight years just to keep up.
MORE SPIN....WHAT THE DEMS WILL SAY
70,000 people will lose health coverage under the GOP budget plan.
REALITY CHECK....WHAT THE GOP IS DOING
Put in reforms to ensure the most needy -children, elderly, and disabled, have appropriate coverage. The 70,000 figure is based on the 2003 eligibility reforms and is SUPER inflated. The actual number of people that were disenrolled due to the changes was 11,300. This year's changes are expected to impact another 1,600.
Overall, Minnesota is very generous with its public health care. Minnesota ranks #1 in the nation for per capita spending on public health programs and the have the lowest uninsured rate in the nation per the UnitedHealth Foundation State Health rankings. In fact, many other states do not even have a comparable program to MinnesotaCare.
